In the vast tapestry of animated cinema, some films shine brightly, while others, like a rare, shimmering pearl, hold a unique and enduring charm, often known only to discerning enthusiasts. Among these captivating curiosities is the 1962 American animated musical, Gay Purr-ee. Produced by United Productions of America (UPA) and distributed by Warner Bros., this feature stands as a fascinating intersection of artistic ambition, superstar vocal talent, and a narrative that, while sometimes meandering, delivers an undeniably memorable experience. But what truly makes this feline-centric Parisian adventure a cult classic and a talking point in animation history?
At its heart, Gay Purr-ee tells a classic tale of innocence lost and found, set against a vibrantly painted backdrop. Our story begins in the serene French countryside, where the spirited farm cat, Mewsette (voiced by the legendary Judy Garland), yearns for a life beyond her simple existence. Disillusioned with her "plebeian" routine and the affections of her earnest boyfriend, Jaune-Tom (crooned by the charismatic Robert Goulet), Mewsette dreams of Parisian glamour, fueled by romanticized notions.
Spurred by a fit of pique, Mewsette stows away to the French capital, believing it holds the key to her sophisticated aspirations. However, Paris proves to be less a dream and more a cleverly woven snare. She quickly falls under the deceptive spell of the conniving alley cat, Meowrice (brought to life by the versatile Paul Frees), who promises to transform her into a proper Parisian lady. His true intentions, however, are far more sinister: to facilitate an underhanded "matchmaking" deal, intending to sell Mewsette into a forced marriage with an unappealing, wealthy American cat.
Meanwhile, back on the farm, a dejected Jaune-Tom, accompanied by his loyal but somewhat cynical friend, Robespierre (voiced by Red Buttons), embarks on a determined quest to find his beloved Mewsette. Their journey to Paris is fraught with its own challenges, as they navigate the bustling city, often at the mercy of Meowrice's machinations, which even include shipping Robespierre off to Alaska! The plot, a charmingly tangled web, explores themes of misguided ambition, loyalty, and the surprising dangers lurking beneath a city's glittering facade.
Perhaps one of Gay Purr-ee's most undeniable strengths lies in its extraordinary vocal talent. Securing performers of this caliber for an animated feature was a testament to the film's aspirations and remains a significant draw for audiences today. Imagine the star power!
For many, the very mention of Gay Purr-ee immediately brings to mind Judy Garland. As Mewsette, Garland imbues the character with her signature blend of youthful naivete, underlying vulnerability, and, of course, that incomparable singing voice. Her performance elevates Mewsette from a mere cartoon feline to a relatable ingénue, making her desires and subsequent dilemmas genuinely felt. It's a testament to her talent that even in a less-than-perfect story, her presence shines.
Matching Garland's vocal prowess is Robert Goulet as Jaune-Tom. At the time, Goulet was a Broadway sensation, fresh off his success in "Camelot," and his smooth, powerful baritone lent an air of dashing heroism to the earnest farm cat. His musical numbers are among the film's most memorable, including the catchy "Bubbles," a comedic ode to champagne. His portrayal ensures Jaune-Tom is more than just a rescuer; he's a devoted, endearing protagonist.
The film also benefits immensely from the vocal chicanery of Paul Frees, a legendary voice actor known for his incredible range and ability to portray multiple characters. As the villainous Meowrice, Frees delivers a performance that is both menacing and comically flamboyant, perfectly capturing the character's manipulative charm. The supporting cast, including Red Buttons as the surprisingly cynical Robespierre, further enriches the audio landscape, proving that even with limited animation, strong voice work can create vivid personalities.
While some critiques touch upon the film's "limited animation" compared to Disney's elaborate productions, to focus solely on that would be to miss the forest for the trees. Gay Purr-ee is celebrated for its truly unique and artistically ambitious art direction, a stylistic choice that sets it apart from its contemporaries and contributes immensely to its enduring appeal.
The film's visual style leans heavily into an impressionistic aesthetic, a radical departure from the more realistic or character-focused animation prevalent at the time. Paris is rendered not as a photorealistic city, but as a vibrant, almost painted canvas of swirling colors, evocative brushstrokes, and simplified, yet highly expressive, shapes. This artistic choice creates an atmosphere that is both whimsical and sophisticated, perfectly complementing the film's French setting and often fantastical plot points. It's truly one of the best examples of the impressionist cartoon genre, offering a visual experience unlike any other.
One particular sequence stands out as a triumph of conceptual animation: the scene where Meowrice showcases Mewsette's "portraits." Here, Mewsette is not only depicted in the distinct styles of famous artists like Vincent Van Gogh, Pablo Picasso, Henri Matisse, and Edgar Degas, but the segment also offers subtle, insightful commentary on their artistic processes. It's a brilliant meta-moment, demonstrating the animators' deep understanding of art history and their daring willingness to break conventional animation norms. This sequence alone makes the film worth viewing for any animation enthusiast.
With a cast featuring musical theatre and Hollywood legends like Judy Garland and Robert Goulet, it's no surprise that the music of Gay Purr-ee is a highlight. The songs, penned by E.Y. Harburg (who famously contributed to The Wizard of Oz), infuse the film with charm, humor, and emotional depth.
The soundtrack is not merely incidental; it's an integral part of the storytelling, allowing the characters to express their deepest feelings and motivations through song, a hallmark of classic animated musicals.
While Gay Purr-ee boasts undeniable strengths, it's also a film that elicits discussion regarding its more unconventional elements. Some viewers find its narrative a bit "messy" or its world-building inconsistent. For instance, why are these cats so concerned with human currency and engaging in human-like businesses, yet also retain animalistic tendencies like mousing, and even have human owners? These questions highlight a delightful, if at times perplexing, blend of anthropomorphism and animal realism.
"The movie's worth a look for fans of Goulet and Garland as well as animation fans, but it's decidedly less than the sum of its parts."
Character motivations, particularly Mewsette's initial discontent, aren't always deeply explored, leading some to feel the character's impulsive actions are somewhat underdeveloped. And the suggestion that Robespierre's eagerness to get rid of Mewsette is rooted in a desire to spend more time with Jaune-Tom adds another layer of playful, if unintended, subtext to their friendship. These quirks, however, are often what make the film so endearing and endlessly rewatchable, inviting viewers to chuckle at its eccentricities rather than be deterred by them.
Despite its initial mixed critical reception and perhaps not reaching blockbuster status, Gay Purr-ee has cemented its place as a beloved cult classic. It represents a significant, albeit final, animated feature project for UPA, a studio known for its stylized and experimental approach to animation that heavily influenced the industry. Its distribution by Warner Bros. also marked a notable moment in the studio's animation history.
The film's endurance can be attributed to several factors:
Absolutely. For animation aficionados keen to explore beyond the mainstream, for fans of classic Hollywood musicals and the incomparable talents of Judy Garland and Robert Goulet, and for anyone seeking a uniquely charming, visually stunning, and delightfully peculiar cinematic experience, Gay Purr-ee is a must-see. It's a testament to the idea that sometimes, the magic isn't in perfection, but in daring to be different. So, settle in, and prepare for a whimsical journey to a Paris seen through the eyes of some very melodious cats.